Tax Avoidance and the Accountant’s Professional Duty: A Review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.60154/jaepp.2024.v25n2p204Keywords:
Tax accounting, Professional ethics, Tax avoidance, Duty to societyAbstract
There is a substantial body of literature in the business ethics field dealing with the ethics of tax avoidance. Some of this literature extends the ethical inquiry to the tax professional, arguing that participation in tax avoidance activities is contrary to the accountant’s professional duty, both in terms of their duty to the public welfare as well as their duty to follow proper accounting practices. The existing literature usually argues from the premises that tax avoidance is detrimental to society, and that the accountant has a largely undefined duty to the welfare of society. If those premises are accepted, the conclusion in the existing literature that participation in tax avoidance activities violates the accountant’s duty to the public interest is unavoidable. It is also argued that accountants have a duty as professionals which would preclude engaging in tax-avoiding activities, irrespective of its impact on the wider society. This paper reviews the existing literature which addresses these topics and evaluates the premises and conclusions which have been largely accepted in the literature. The commonly cited harms to the public interest caused by tax avoidance are reviewed, and the origin, nature, and codification of the accountant’s professional duty are examined. It is argued that not only are the harms caused by tax avoidance often mis- or overstated, but that the professional duty of the accountant is misspecified as well. Since these are critical premises to the argument that tax avoidance represents a violation of the accountant’s duty to the public interest, the questionable validity of those premises leads to serious reservations about the validity of the conclusion. This paper does not argue that tax avoidance is either ethical or unethical, good or bad, moral or immoral. The sole purpose of this paper is to examine whether it is correct to argue that the accountant’s professional duty to the public interest would prohibit condoning or participating in tax avoidance activities.
References
1. Abbott (1983). Professional ethics. American Journal of Sociology, 88, 856-885.
2. Addison , S. and Mueller, F. (2015). The dark side of professions: the big four and tax avoidance. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 28(8), 1263-1290.
3. American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Statement on standards for tax services no. 1, tax return positions. https://www.aicpa.org/resources/article/statement-on-standards-for-tax-services-no-1-tax-return-positions. Accessed 2 Janunary, 2023.
4. Backoff, Jeanne F. and Charles L. Martin, Jr. (1991). Historical perspectives: Development of the codes of ethics in the legal, medical and accounting professions. Journal of Business Ethics, 10(2) 99-110.
5. Bastiat, Frédéric. The Law (FEE ed.). Foundation for Economic Education, 1998.
6. Bastiat, Frédéric. The Collected Works of Frédéric Bastiat. Vol. 3: Economic Sophisms and “What is Seen and What is Not Seen”. Liberty Fund, 2017.
7. Bird, Robert and Karie Davis-Nozemack (2018). Tax avoidance as a sustainability problem. Journal of Business Ethics 151(4), 1009 – 1025.
8. Brody, R. G., and Masselli, J. J. (1996). Tax preparers: Whose team are they on? The National Public Accountant, 41(3), 18–20.
9. Chodorov, Frank, The Income Tax: The Root of all Evil, The Devin-Adair Company, New York, 1954.
10. Ciravegna, L., & Nieri, F. (2022). Business and human rights: A configurational view of the antecedents of human rights infringements by emerging market firms. Journal of Business Ethics, 179(2), 431-450. doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-021-04861-w
11. Darcy, Shane (2017). The elephant in the room: corporate tax avoidance & business and human rights. Business and Human Rights Journal 2(1), 1-30.
12. Datt, Kalmen (2014). Paying a fair share of tax and aggressive tax planning – A tale of two myths. eJournal of Tax Research, 12(2), 410-432.
13. Datt, Kalmen (2018). Tax and human rights – much ado about nothing. eJournal of Tax Research, 16(1), 113-138
14. Davis, H.Z. and J.A. Strawser (1993). The accounting profession: expert witness and/or advocate. Critical Perspectives in Accounting 4(2), 141-154.
15. de Colle, Simone, and Ann Marie Bennett (2014). State-induced, strategic, or toxic? An ethical analysis of tax avoidance practices. Business & Professional Ethics Journal 33(1), 53–82.
16. Dellaportas, Steven and Laura Davenport (2008). Reflections on the public interest in accounting. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 19, 1080-1098.
17. Dole, Elaine, Jane Frecknall-Hughes, and Barbara Summers (2014). Ethics in tax practice: A study of the effect of practitioner firm size. Journal of Business Ethics, 122(4), 623-641.
18. Dowling, Grahame R. The Curious Case of Corporate Tax Avoidance: Is it Socially Irresponsible?. Journal of Business Ethics 124, 173–184 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-013-1862-4
19. Fatemi, Darius, John Hasseldine, and Peggy Hite (2020). The influence of ethical codes on professionalism in tax practice. Journal of Business Ethics 164(1), 133-149.
20. Finn, D.W., Chonko, L.B. & Hunt, S.D. (1988). Ethical problems in public accounting: The view from the top. Journal of Business Ethics 7(8), 605–615 (1988).
21. Frecknal-Hughes, Jane, Peter Moizer, Elaine Doyle, and Barbara Summers (2017). An examination of ethical influences on the work of tax practitioners. Journal of Business Ethics, 146(4), 729-745.
22. Freedman, Judith, (2012). Responsive regulation, risk, and rules: Applying the theory to tax practice.
23. UBC Law Review 44(3) 627.
24. Geraghty, Karen (2001). Viewpoint - Commemorative Issue: Guarding the art, Edmund D. Pellegrino, MD. AMA Journal of Ethics 3(11), 405-407.
25. Greenwood, Ernest (1960). Attributes of a profession. The New Outlook, May 1960, 169-177.
26. Hansen, Don R., Rick L. Crosser, and Doug Laufer (1992). Moral ethics v. tax ethics: The case of transfer pricing among multinational corporations. Journal of Business Ethics 11(9), 679-686.
27. Helfeld, Jan (2008, August 23). Reid "Taxation Is Voluntary [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6q0slMhDw8
28. Henderson, B. C., & Kaplan, S. E. (2005). An examination of the role of ethics in tax compliance decisions. The Journal of the American Taxation Association 27(1), 39-72.
29. Hoppe, Hans-Herman. Democracy: The God That Failed. Taylor & Francis, London, 2001.
30. International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (2023). Handbook of the International Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants. https://ifacweb.blob.core.windows.net/publicfiles/2024-03/2023%20IESBA%20Handbook%20-%20Updated%203-26-24_0_0.pdf
31. Jackson, B. R., & Milliron, V. C. (1989). Tax preparers: Government agents or client advocates? Journal of Accountancy 167(5), 76-82.
32. Joplin, J. Porter (1919). Growing responsibilities of the public accountant. The Journal of Accountancy 28(1), 9-15.
33. Krupka, Joseph (2019). Recommitment to advancing accounting ethics. Journal of Accounting, Ethics, & Public Policy 20(1), 1-29.
34. Lenz, Hansrudi (2020). Aggressive tax avoidance by managers of multinational companies as a violation of their moral duty to obey the law: A Kantian rationale. Journal of Business Ethics 165(4), 681–697.
35. Locke, John. (1689) Second Treatise of Government. Reprint, Indianapolis, Hackett Publishing Company, Inc., 1980.
36. Lokanan, Mark (2023). The morality and tax avoidance: A sentiment and position taking analysis. PLoS ONE 18(7): e0287327 (1-33).
37. McGee, Robert W. (1998). Should Accountants Be Punished for Aiding and Abetting Tax Evasion? Journal of Accounting, Ethics and Public Policy, 1(1), 19-51. https://ssrn.com/abstract=2691859
38. Murphy, Brid and Ann Marie Bennett (2018). Accounting for public interest. Accountancy Plus, 02, 3-6.
39. Neu, Dean; Cameron, Graham (2005). Accounting research and the public interest, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 18(5), 585-591.
40. Payne, Dinah M. and Cecily A. Raiborn (2018). Aggressive tax avoidance: A conundrum for stakeholders, governments, and morality. Journal of Business Ethics 147(3), 469-487.
41. Edmund D Pellegrino 2002). “Professionalism, profession and the virtues of the good physician.
42. Mt Sinai Journal of Medicine 69(6), 378-84.
43. Schwartz, R.D. and Orleans, S. (1967). On legal sanctions, University of Chicago Law Review 34, 274-300.
44. Shafer, W. E., & Simmons, R. S. (2008). Social responsibility, Machiavellianism and tax avoidance. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal 21(5), 695–720.
45. Sikka, Prem and M Hampton (2005). The role of accountancy firms in tax avoidance: Some evidence and issues. Accounting Forum 29(3), 325-343.
46. Sikka, Prem. (2008). Enterprise culture and accountancy firms: new masters of the universe. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 21(2), 268-295.
47. Sikka, Prem (2015). The hand of accounting and accountancy firms in deepening income and wealth inequalities and the economic crisis: some evidence. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 30, p 46-62.
48. Sivakumar Velayutham (2003). The accounting profession’s code of ethics: Is it a code of ethics or a code of quality assurance? Critical Perspectives on Accounting 14(4), 483-503.
49. Smith, G. Stevenson (2007). Maurice Stans’ Views on Social Responsibility in the Accounting Profession. Accounting Historians Journal 34(1), 147-172.
50. Spooner, Lysander. No Treason. No. VI. The Constitution of No Authority (1870). Lysander Spooner, 1870.
51. Stainer, Alan, Lorice Stainer, and Alexandra Segal (1997). The Ethics of Tax Planning. A European Review 6(4), 213-219.
52. Stuebs, M. Jr., & Wilkinson, B. (2009). Restoring the profession’s public interest role. CPA Journal, November 2009, 62 – 66.
53. West, Andrew (2018). Multinational Tax Avoidance: Virtue Ethics and the Role of Accountants. Journal of Business Ethics 153(4), 1143 – 1156.
54. Williams, P. (1987). The legitimate concern with fairness. Accounting, Organizations and Society 12(2), 169-89.
55. Willmott, Hugh Christopher (1990). Serving the Public Interest? A Critical Analysis of a Professional Claim. In D. Cooper & T. Hopper (eds.), Critical accounts,. Critical Accounts, (pp. 315-331). The Macmillan Press, Houndmills, UK.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Thomas T. Amlie
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
