Does Religiosity and LGBTQ Inclusiveness Impact The Probability of Financial Statement Manipulation?

Authors

  • Benjamin P. Foster College of Business, University of Louisville, USA
  • Dianna Preece College of Business, University of Louisville, USA

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.60154/jaepp.2024.v25n2p52

Keywords:

Diversity, Religiosity, LGBTQ, Corporate Equality Index, M-score, Earnings Management, Financial Manipulation

Abstract

 

Previous research finds that greater gender diversity and inclusion in firms, on boards of directors, and on audit committees, improves the quality of financial reporting, lowers the likelihood of accounting restatements, and decreases the likelihood of financial misconduct. This is the first study to examine whether lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgendered, queer, or questioning (LGBTQ) diversity in companies will also result in higher ethical actions regarding financial statements. With regression analyses, this study examines whether companies’ Corporate Equality Index (CEI) ratings of support for the LGBTQ community, as a measure of diversity, help explain companies’ M-scores or manipulation scores, a measure of accounting-based earnings manipulation. Likewise, we examine if the religiosity of the county where a company is headquartered influences the company’s manipulation score because previous research finds that companies headquartered in more religious areas are less likely to engage in financial misconduct. We conduct OLS and logistic regression analysis with M-score as the dependent variable, and headquarters area religiosity and company CEI ratings as independent variables of interest. Regression results provide little indication that the people's religiosity in the county where a corporate headquarters is located affects the firm’s M-score. However, we find that the higher the CEI rating, the lower the probability of financial statement manipulation as measured by the M-score. This study sheds light on an underexplored aspect of corporate governance and diversity, further reinforcing the notion that diversity benefits companies in many ways, including those tied to governance.

References

Arun, Thankom, Yousf Almahrog, and Zakaria Aribi. 2015. “Female Directors and Earnings Management: Evidence from U.K. Companies.” International Review of Financial Analysis. 39(C): 137 – 146.

Beneish, Messod. 1999. “The Detection of Earnings Manipulation.” Financial Analysts Journal. 55(5): 24 – 36.

Beneish, Messod, Charles Lee and Craig Nichols. 2013. “Earnings Manipulation and Expected Returns.” Financial Analysts Journal. 69(2): 57 – 82.

Chan, Lillian, Kevin Chen, Tai Chen and Yangxin Yu. 2015. “Substitution Between Real and Accruals-Based Earnings Management After Voluntary Adoption of Compensation Clawback Provisions.” The Accounting Review. 90(1): 147 – 174.

Chircop, Justin, Michele Fabrizi, Elisabetta Ipino, and Antonio Parbonetti. 2017. “Does Branch Religiosity Influence Bank Risk-taking?” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 44(1–2): 271–294.

Chourou, Lamia, Luo He, and Ligang Zhong. 2020 “Does Religiosity Enhance the Quality of Management Earnings Forecasts?” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 47(7–8): 910–948

Cui, Jinhua, Hoje Jo, Haejung Na and Manuel G. Valasquez. 2015. “Workforce Diversity and Religiosity.” Journal of Business Ethics. 128(4): 743-767.

Dyreng, Scott, William Mayew, and Christopher D. Williams. 2012. “Religious Social Norms and Corporate Financial Reporting.” Journal of Business Finance & Accounting. 39(7–8): 845–875

Felix, Robert, Mikhail Pevzner, and Mengxin Zhao. 2021. "Cultural Diversity of Audit Committees and Firms' Financial Reporting Quality." Accounting Horizons. 35.3:143 - 159.

Foster, Benjamin, Andrew Manikas and Dianna Preece. 2021. “Impact of Religiosity on LGBTQ Inclusiveness and Corporate Value.” Journal of Accounting, Ethics and Public Policy. 22(3): 347 – 365.

Foster, Benjamin, Andrew Manikas, and Dianna Preece. 2020. “LGBTQ Workplace Inclusion Before and After Obergefell v. Hodges: Association with Tobin’s q and ROA.” Journal of Accounting, Ethics and Public Policy. 21(4): 481 – 514.

Garcia-Sanchez, Isabella-Maria, Jennifer Martinez-Ferrero, Emma Garcia-Meca. 2017. “Gender Diversity, Financial Expertise and Its Effects on Accounting Quality.” Management Decision. 55(2): 347 – 382.

Johansson, Anna. 2017. “Why Workplace Diversity Diminishes Groupthink and How Millennials are Helping.” Forbes. Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/annajohansson/2017/07/20/how-workplace-diversity-diminishes-groupthink-and-how-millennials-are-helping/?sh=c7892854b741

Human Rights Campaign, https://www.hrc.org/resources/corporate-equality-index. Accessed April 29, 2024.

Kanagaretnam, Kiridaran, Gerald J. Lobo, and Chong Wang. 2015. "Religiosity and Earnings Management: International Evidence from the Banking Industry." Journal of Business Ethics. 132.2: 277-96.

Labelle, Ré, Rim Makni Gargouri, and Claude Francoeur. 2010. "Ethics, Diversity Management, and Financial Reporting Quality." Journal of Business Ethics. 93(2): 335-53.

Levine, Carolyn and Michael Smith. 2019. “Clawbacks and Earnings Management.” Journal of Accounting Management Research. 31(3): 129-151.

Mahmood, Kahkashan, Yasser Barghathi and Alhashmi Lasyoud. 2021. “Exploring the Potentials of Clawbacks to Check Earnings Management Practices and Enhance Financial Reporting Quality: Perceptions from the UAE.” Qualitative Research in Financial Markets. 13(3): 359-382.

Man, Chi-keung and Brossa Wong. 2013. "Corporate Governance and Earnings Management: A Survey." Journal of Applied Business Research 29.2: 391-418.

McGuire, Sean T., Thomas C. Omer, and Nathan Y. Sharp. 2012. "The Impact of Religion on Financial Reporting Irregularities." The Accounting Review. 87(2): 645-73.

Reidenbach, R. Eric and Donald P. Robin. 1991. “A Conceptual Model of Corporate Moral Development.” Journal of Business Ethics. 10(4): 273 – 284.

Sari, Ratna Candra, and Mahfud Sholihin. 2019. "Religiosity and Clawback Provision to Curb Earnings Management." Journal of Management, Spirituality & Religion. 16(4): 372-90.

USC Dorsife Center for Religion and Civic Culture. 2021. https://crcc.usc.edu.

Velte, Patrick. 2020. “Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) and Earnings Management: A Literature Review.” Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3755451

Wahid, Aida Sijamic. 2019. "The Effects and the Mechanisms of Board Gender Diversity: Evidence from Financial Manipulation." Journal of Business Ethics. 159(3): 705-25.

Wei, Zuobao, and Yicheng Zhu. 2023. "Does Religiosity Improve Analyst Forecast Accuracy?" Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting. 60.3: 915-48.

Downloads

Published

2024-06-08

How to Cite

Foster, B. P., & Preece, D. (2024). Does Religiosity and LGBTQ Inclusiveness Impact The Probability of Financial Statement Manipulation?. Journal of Accounting, Ethics & Public Policy, JAEPP, 25(2), 52. https://doi.org/10.60154/jaepp.2024.v25n2p52